CMS-Based Online Teaching Using Desire2Learn

CMS-Based Online Teaching

Effective Student Learning Outcomes

Introduction
Whether you are developing a new course or revamping a current course, writing effective Student Learning Outcomes (or Performance Objectives) is a critical component toward developing a sound, functioning course. Spending copious amounts of time in the beginning of course design in an effort to decide what you want students to learn and articulating that message well will pay off as you determine teaching activities and assessment strategies. The information in this document is designed to offer a starting point for reflection regarding your student outcomes identified for your course and assist you in writing effective and assessable student learning outcomes.
How to Best Use This Information
  • If you already have a course you are teaching, pull out your syllabus and make notes as the various ideas are presented.
  • If you are developing SLOs for a new course, pull out a blank sheet of paper and start making notes – you can refine your statements over time once the general reflection process is complete.
  • Why start with student outcomes?
  • Student learning outcomes “steer” your course – taking time up front to clearly articulate them will direct your teaching/learning activities as well as your assessment strategies (see worksheet at end).
  • Students will know what they are expected to learn as a part of the course.
  • Ultimately measure if student learning is taking place and if any alterations need to be made in the process towards student learning.
  • Nine Principles of Good Practice for Assessing Student Learning: http://itc.utk.edu/newsletter/spring_04/principles.shtml
  • Confusing Terminology
    Terminology surrounding learning outcomes can be confusing depending on what authors you read. Terms such as goals, objectives and outcomes are often used interchangeably. For the purpose of this project, the terminology of Student Learning Outcome (SLO) will be used and defined as descriptions of what students or participants are expected to learn. If you would prefer to use the terms performance objectives, performance outcomes, instructional objectives, learning objectives, etc., you can certainly do so, just so you are creating them according to the context of the definition above.
    Reflective factors affecting your course
    These are broad-based questions to ask yourself as you are making decision on what students should learn in your course, how it will be delivered, and how it should be assessed.
    Who are my students/participants? Where does my course sit in the bigger scheme? Are there other requirements of the University?
    • How Many Students?
    • Level (grad/undergrad)?
    • Traditional or Non-Traditional?
    • Learning Styles?
    • Intellectual Development Stages?
    • What does society need from these students?
    • Previous knowledge with material or life experience?
    • Implications of an online environment?
    • Are you autonomous in developing SLOs or are they impacted by external influences?
    • Is your course an elective course?
    • Is your course a part of the general education core? System (SGEs), Institutional (IGRs)
    • Is your course a part of a program?
    • Implications of professional agencies/accrediting bodies?
    • Impact of state, department, college or institution?
    Consider Lead Forward Goals:
    • Internationally Competitive
    • Globally informed
    • Communication – able in speaking, writing and tech
    • Able to Embrace Change in Positive Ways
    • Socially Responsible
    Writing Student Learning Outcomes: As you write your outcomes they should clearly answer two (2) basic questions.
    1. When a student completes this course, he or she will…
    2. What impact do you want this course to have on students that will still be there after the course is over?
    A. Knowledge, Skills and Abilities (KSAs) – Bloom’s Taxonomy

    This is a very nice link that discusses pragmatically the three domains of learning as described by Bloom’s Taxonomy. It is a good link to keep handy since it not only serves as a reminder as to the different levels of learning, but also provides a nice supply of action verbs to help drive the writing of your outcomes: http://www.nwlink.com/~donclark/hrd/bloom.html

    At what level, simple to complex, will I require student to achieve? (think about higher education)

    Cognitive Domain

    Objectives related to information or knowledge, naming, solving, predicting, and other intellectual aspects of learning: Knowledge, Comprehension, Application, Analysis, Synthesis, Evaluation

    Psychomotor Domain

    Encompasses skills requiring the use and coordination of skeletal muscles, as in the physical activities of performing, manipulating and constructing

    Affective Domain

    Objectives related to attitudes, appreciations, values, emotions such as enjoying, conserving and respecting.

    B. Are there qualities that students should be achieving through or beyond the content? Some examples may be:

    C. How to specifically write outcome statements: This link is available through Education Technology at SDSU to provide a more prescriptive approach in actually writing outcome statements: http://ids.sdstate.edu/WebCT/Resources/detail.cfm?PostID=149
    From Performance Instruction: Planning, Delivering, Evaluating
    Daniel E. Vogler  
    Instruction Performance Systems, Inc.
    Eden Prairie, MN, 1991  
    Although performance objectives are written in a wide variety of styles, three elements generally can be included in the specification of a performance objective.
    1. The statement of an observable behavior or performance on the part of the learner. Usually it should appropriately complete the statement, "The student will..."
    2. The prescription of a minimally acceptable performance standard on the part of the learner. This must translate the student's performance into measurable terms. Measurement implies a numeric criterion. Four broad classifications of numeric criteria are:
      1. quantity
      2. quality
      3. efficiency
      4. durability

      The standard of a performance objective must contain a criterion in at least one of the four classifications to be technically correct.
    1. An elaboration of the conditions under which learner behavior of performance is to occur. The conditions of the performance objective must communicate the situation, including setting and resources that will be provided to the learner.

    For clear performance objectives

    1. Keep sentences short.
    2. Use few multiple-syllable words.
    3. Adopt common formats – requires similar amount of learning time.

    Performance objective example

    The student will be provided a list of 200 math terms, no references, and a timed test after instruction (condition). The student will define math terms (observable behavior). Performance will be satisfactory if all 200 terms are defined consistent with the text in 100 minutes for a testing three months after completion of formal instruction (standard: quantity, quality, efficiency, and durability).

    Checklist for Effective Outcomes
    ___ LOs answer the statement: “At the end of this course, the student will be able to…”
    ___ LOs describe outcomes that are measurable…
            Outcomes begin with action verbs
    ___ LOs address initial or mastery level of content KSAs
            Three Domains of Bloom’s (Knowledge, Skills, Affective)
    ___ LOs address critical thinking and increased learning skill
    ___ LOs are clearly stated and understandable to learner
    ___ LOs are articulated and specified for each module/unit level
    ___ Instructions on how students will meet LOs are adequate, clearly written and easy to understand
    ___ Manageable number of LOs (3-5 but no more than 10)
    References and Other Resources
    The following references were used in developing this information or would be valuable sources of information.
  • Nine Principles for Assessing Student Learning: http://itc.utk.edu/newsletter/spring_04/principles.shtml
  • Learning Domains of Bloom’s Taxonomy, Interpreted by Don Clark: http://www.nwlink.com/~donclark/hrd/bloom.html
  • Educational Technology Center, SDSU: http://ids.sdstate.edu/WebCT/Resources/detail.cfm?PostID=149
  • Summer 2004: Course Redesign Strategy; Educational Technology Center/SDSU; Adapted (with permission) from training model designed by Barbara Woovard of the Kaneb Center at Notre Dame.
    Worksheet Idea
    Directions: Whether teaching in the classroom (face-to-face) or utilizing technology to partially or completely deliver your course, use the following matrix to help plan the entire process before developing a new course or revising one that you currently teach.
  • In the first column write in the leaning outcomes.
  • In the second column write in the teaching/learning activity (perhaps you would like to extend beyond a typical content lecture – there are lots of great strategies).
  • In the third column, write in the best way to provide assessment of whether or not students are achieving your outcomes (think about direct objective, direct performance and indirect measures of assessment). 
  • Learning Outcome

    Teaching Learning Activity

    Assessment Strategy

    1.    
    2.    
    3.    
    4.    
    5.    
    6.    
    7.    
    8.    
    9.    
    10.    
    © 2007 South Dakota State University Instructional Design Services. All rights reserved.